Why Most Annual Reviews Miss the Mark
An annual treasury management review is one of the most valuable relationship touchpoints a community bank has with its business clients — and one of the most underused. Done well, it’s a conversation that strengthens your client relationships and adds real value to them. Done poorly, it becomes an obvious checkbox exercise where you are just making sure your clients aren’t actively leaving.
What separates those two outcomes usually isn’t the relationship or how sophisticated a particular client is. It’s the structure of the review itself. Most annual reviews don’t work because there’s no clear agenda, a focus on the wrong questions, or a positioning issue where the review feels like a compliance check on product usage rather than a conversation geared toward improving how the client’s business runs.
Below, you’ll find a full annual review checklist: what to cover, what to leave out, how to run the conversation, and how to turn every review into an upsell opportunity without making it feel like a sales pitch.
What Annual Reviews Should (And Shouldn’t) Accomplish
What They Should
A good annual review accomplishes four things:
1. Confirms services are working as intended.
Make sure your client leaves the review feeling like every product they have is delivering its promised value and actually making operations easier.
2. Surface unmet needs or business changes
Have there been changes in the client’s business or operational needs that mean adjustments or additions to their treasury management suite should happen for next year?
3. Reinforce the relationship
Make them feel cared for. This review should not give any client the idea that you’re checking off a box. It should end with them feeling like you really care about what their business needs.
4. Create natural upsell opportunities
Over the course of your conversation, identify at least one gap or enhancement opportunity within the existing relationship that would be a simple upsell. And it needs to be something you can deliver immediate value on, so the addition feels like a relationship upgrade instead of a sales push.
What They Shouldn’t
It’s equally as important to understand what a review should not involve:
1. Reviewing every transaction or statement
Don’t take time reconciling statements or going through transactions with a fine-tooth comb. You’re there to assess whether a client’s treasury management setup matches what they actually need.
2. Training on existing products
If you have a client who still can’t use a product they’ve already had for a year, that should be a separate, dedicated session. This session’s sole focus needs to be on strategy and product fit.
3. Selling products because they’re in your catalog
Any upsells should be targeted toward an actual gap the client in front of you is experiencing. Presenting a list of available products that don’t directly solve a problem they’re facing lessens the impact and tangible value of your review.
Preparing for the Review
How an annual review goes is largely determined by the preparation that happens before it. When you sit down with a client, make sure you’ve looked at the following data points:
· Service usage summary: What TM products are enabled and how often each one actually gets used.
· Transaction volume trends: If check, ACH, and wire activity is increasing, decreasing, or staying flat.
· Fraud controls status: Enablement of positive pay, ACH filters, dual control, and alerts, as well as the last date they were reviewed.
· Support ticket history: If support ticket patterns suggest a product isn’t working well or is configured incorrectly.
· Relationship profitability: Total relationship value (deposits + loans + TM fee income).
· Last fraud review or controls assessment: When the last time was that you reviewed fraud controls with this client and what gaps were identified.
And then you’ll need to answer some preliminary questions based on the data you’ve collected:
· What has changed in this client's business over the past year? (New locations, new products, growth, contraction, ownership changes, etc.)
· What products are underutilized or dormant? Why?
· What gaps exist in their current fraud controls or payment workflows?
· What’s the most relevant upsell for this client based on their transaction patterns and current gaps?
The Agenda That Will Keep Your Review On Track
Structure your client 's conversation so it progresses logically from confirmation to discovery to recommendation, rather than jumping right into a product list.
Minutes 0–5: Open with a business update
"Thank you for making time for this annual treasury management review. My goal today is to confirm everything is working well, get to the bottom of any needs or changes in your business, and make sure your treasury management setup is still aligned with how you operate. Before we dive into your current services, can you give me a rundown of the changes your business has seen in the last year? Tell me about any growth, new challenges, or changes in how you’re managing your cash flow."
This opening question often surfaces needs the client would not think to mention if you started by reviewing their current product list.
Minutes 5–20: Service Usage and Satisfaction
You can use a version of the same three basic questions to review each major service your client is using:
· How often do they use each product?
· Are they able to use the products without frustration?
· Has the client experienced a time in the last year when a product didn’t do what they needed?
Review every major enabled service and note whether the client is satisfied, whether usage has changed, and whether there are any gaps or pain points.
Minutes 20–30: Fraud Controls Assessment
"Let's talk about fraud controls for a few minutes. We’ve seen [specific fraud trend relevant to their industry] increase significantly over the past year. I want to make sure the controls you have enabled match your current risk profile."
Questions to ask:
· When was the last time the client reviewed their user access list? Have any employees left or changed roles in the past year?
· Are they receiving daily alerts on account activity? Who’s in charge of reviewing them?"
· Has the client experienced any fraud attempts or suspicious activity in the past year?
· Do they have positive pay enabled? [If yes: How often do they get exceptions? If no: Based in the number of checks written, consider recommending that product addition.]
· Do they have ACH filters set up to block unauthorized debits? [If no: Explain why filters are an operational necessity]
Work on identifying at least one fraud control gap that creates a natural upsell opportunity.
Minutes 30–40: Unmet Needs and Enhancement Opportunities
"Based on what we’ve covered, I can see a few opportunities to improve your setup. Let me walk through what I’m thinking."
Present one or two specific recommendations based on gaps you identified with the client during your conversation. Don’t present a menu of options. Only present targeted recommendations that actual address those gaps.
As an example, this might be how you address a client dealing with potential mail fraud from manual checks:
"You mentioned writing about 30 checks a month, and that you’ve had a couple situations where checks got delayed or lost in the mail. To mitigate those circumstances as much as possible, I’d recommend adding positive pay. It’s a check validation service that stops fraudulent or altered checks before they clear. You’d only pay $50 a month and eliminate the risk of a counterfeit or altered check clearing without your knowledge. Would you like to explore enabling the service?"
Minutes 40–45: Pricing, Next Steps, and Close
If you get immediate agreement:
"Great. I’m going to go ahead and get a 20-minute call on the calendar for [specific date and time] and we’ll get this all set up for you. You’ll get that invite in the next couple minutes."
If the client still needs time to think:
"No problem. Let's put 15 minutes on the calendar for [specific date] to answer any questions and move forward if it makes sense. Will that work for you?"
Close by confirming the next review date:
"We’ll do this again in 12 months. I’ll reach out in [month/year] to get it on your calendar. In the meantime, if anything changes in your business or you have questions about your setup, just reach out. I’m always available to help."
Turn Every Review Into an Upsell Opportunity Without Feeling Pushy
The most successful upsells come from reviews that uncover real unmet needs, not from those overtly pushing products. There are a few things you can do to bring about that result naturally.
Lead with the Gap, Not the Product
Simply asking if a client wants a product is almost always ineffective. A strong upsell makes it clear how the product would provide an immediate fix to an operational pain point.
A strong upsell for dual controls might look a bit like the following:
"You told me your bookkeeper can send wires without outside approval. So if their login ever got compromised or someone outside the bank sent a convincing email asking them to send funds, nothing would be there to stop that transfer from happening. Dual approval makes sure you always have a second set of eyes on money in motion. Does that make sense as an addition to your product suite?"
Position Upsells as Solutions to Problems the Client Recognizes
If the client hasn’t told you about a problem that you’re seeing, guide them to it:
"One thing I noticed is that you don’t have ACH filters enabled, which means any company with your account number can attempt a debit. There’s no control stopping unauthorized debits before they hit your account. Given the size of the balances in your operating account, I’d recommend adding ACH filters to control who can debit you. Here’s how that would work."
Present One or Two High-Impact Recommendations
Don’t overwhelm the client with five different upsell options. Identify the one or two gaps that matter most and present those clearly. You can address other opportunities in future reviews.
Following Up Post-Review
The review does not end when the meeting ends. Follow-up determines whether recommendations turn into implementations.
Within 2 hours of the end of the review, your client should receive a summary email:
Subject: Treasury Management Annual Review Summary — Next Steps
Body:
"Hi [Name], thank you for taking time with me to hold our annual treasury management review today. Here’s a quick summary of everything we covered:
Services reviewed: [list]
Recommendations discussed: [specific products or enhancements]
Next steps: [implementation call scheduled, follow-up call scheduled, or no action needed]
If you have any questions before our next call, let me know and I’ll get back to you as soon as possible. Thanks again."
For a verbal agreement on an upsell, have the implementation call within the next week. And if the client still needs time to think, make sure you’ve scheduled a follow-up call for that same timeframe.
Once implementation happens, immediately put a 30-day check-in on the calendar to confirm the client is using it and seeing value.
The Annual Review Calendar and Tracking System
None of this can happen consistently without an annual calendar and some basic tracking.
Segment your treasury management portfolio and spread reviews evenly across the year so you’re conducting roughly the same number of reviews each month. A 120-client portfolio breaks down to about 10 reviews a month, scheduled in the CRM 60 days out, with the RM or TM officer getting a task notification 30 days before each one comes due.
Build a simple dashboard tracking completed reviews against scheduled ones, the share of reviews that turn up at least one upsell opportunity, the share of those recommendations that convert, average upsell value, and total fee income the reviews generated. Look at it quarterly and adjust the process based on what it shows you.
Reviews Should be Conversations About the Relationship
The banks that get the most out of annual TM reviews are the ones that treat them like real conversations about the client’s business. When you are consistently well-prepared and focused on solving real client pain points, you can turn these reviews into one of the highest-value activities of the year.
Restructure your reviews to provide immediate value and relief, and your upsell conversations will convert better than ever before.
Contact us today to learn how you can create a repeatable review structure that upsells effectively.
Related Reads for You
Discover more articles that align with your interests and keep exploring.
