
The Two Questions Leadership Asks in Q4
At some point between the beginning of November and the holiday season, banking leadership will pose two questions to their treasury management teams: what were the numbers this year and what should they be for 2027?
The first question is easy to answer. Your TM team can pull reports in seconds showing fee income, relationship counts, and products sold.
The second question is the one that puts pressure on for the next year. What numbers are you targeting for your program and, by extension, how do you get there?
Leadership needs a figure to plan around, and Q4 is the ideal time to set one. The difficulty is that a year-end review mostly pulls volume, which only tells you how many things happened. It says little about whether clients are using what they bought, whether they are better protected than they were a year ago, or whether the portfolio is getting deeper or only wider.
Take a low positive pay adoption rate. It reads as a gap to close. It may also reflect clients who write few checks, a product priced for a different kind of client, or an RM team that was never given a clear reason to raise it. Each explanation leads to a different decision for 2027, and a campaign aimed at the wrong one will use up hours without moving the number.
This post covers five measures that help separate those explanations, a way to sort what you find into proceed, pilot, defer, or decline, and how to turn the result into goals and a November and December plan.
Five Core Metrics Every TM Team Should Include in the Year-End Review
Product Adoption Rate by Service
For each product (e.g., positive pay, ACH filters, dual control, RDC, wire services, and instant payments), work out what share of eligible clients has adopted it.
How to calculate:
· Positive pay adoption rate: clients with positive pay enabled/clients regularly writing checks
· ACH filter adoption rate: clients with ACH filters enabled/clients processing ACH transactions
· Dual control adoption rate: clients with dual approval enabled/clients with multiple users
A low rate has several possible explanations. Clients may not see what the product does for their situation. The product may not fit how they work. Your team might not be raising pricing consistently, or the price tag might be functioning as a general deterrent.
To find out which of these apply to your program the most, pull a sample of clients without the product and find out which one applies before choosing a response.
Segment before you set a target. A rate across all check writers hides the difference between a client issuing a few low-value checks and one paying vendors by check every week. To discover which of these clients needs your product, ask for which of them it will actually change an outcome.
Reference points to test:
· Positive pay: 75%+ adoption among clients writing 10+ checks per month
· ACH filters: 60%+ adoption among clients processing ACH
· Dual control: 80%+ adoption among clients with 2+ users
If you fall short of your target, audit your sales process. Are RMs and TM officers recommending these products during onboarding and annual reviews? Are objection responses documented? How is your pricing presented?
Pricing framed as protection against a specific loss will always be an easier yes for a client than pricing that is just presented as a cost for the service.
Service Utilization Rate (Active vs. Dormant Products)
Of clients who have products enabled, how many are actually using them?
How to calculate:
· Positive pay: clients who submitted check files in the past 90 days/clients with positive pay enabled
· ACH origination: clients who originated ACH in the past 90 days/clients with ACH origination enabled
An enabled product that sits unused might mean the client never needed it, never learned how to use it, or even stalled right after implementation.
It also means the fee income attached to the product is less secure than you think it is, because a client who notices a charge for something they don’t use may ask to drop it.
Reference points to test:
· 90%+ active usage rate for fraud controls (e.g., positive pay, ACH filters, and dual control)
· 80%+ active usage rate for payment services (e.g, ACH, wires, and RDC)
If you’re below target, outreach to dormant accounts and ask why they’re not using their products. If the client doesn’t need something, remove it and adjust pricing. If they do need it but don’t know how to use it, schedule training.
Fraud Review Completion Rate
What percentage of scheduled fraud reviews were completed this year?
How to calculate:
· Fraud review completion rate: fraud reviews completed/fraud reviews scheduled
Break the results out by client tier to determine where completion is lagging.
Fraud reviews are the primary way banks determine protection gaps and the place where most upsell conversations begin, so a low completion rate has two costs: under-protected clients and unmade recommendations.
Reference points to test:
· 90%+ completion rate for Tier 1 clients (quarterly reviews)
· 80%+ completion rate for Tier 2 clients (semi-annual reviews)
If you’re below target, assess your capacity constraints. Your TM officers may have more clients than the review calendar can handle or the reviews could be taking too long to complete. Scheduled reviews may even be losing priority against an influx of support requests.
Any of these issues will have taken hours, even days, to surface. They won’t be solvable just sending your clients a review reminder.
Upsell Conversion Rate
Of fraud reviews or annual TM reviews that ended in a product recommendation, what percentage resulted in a sale?
How to calculate:
· Upsell conversion rate = product recommendations that converted/product recommendations made
Track each product separately to identify which products convert well and which don’t.
Low conversion has several likely sources. The gap you identified may not match what the client needs or the positioning and/or follow-up cadence might be falling flat.
Reference points to test:
· 40–50% conversion rate for fraud controls recommended during fraud reviews
· 30–40% conversion rate for products recommended during annual TM reviews
If you’re below target, audit the quality of your gap identification and recommendation process. Are gaps specific to the client, or generic? Are recommendations positioned as solutions to problems the client recognizes? Is follow-up consistent?
Fee Income Per Relationship
The average treasury management fee income per relationship, segmented by client tier.
How to calculate:
· Average TM fee income per relationship: average TM fee income/ TM relationships
Track year-over-year growth to determine whether relationships are deepening or stagnating.
This is the best measure of whether your portfolio deepening, with clients using more services, or widening, with more clients on minimal services).
Reference points to test:
· Year-over-year growth of 8–12% in average fee income per relationship
· Tier 1 clients generating 3–5x the fee income of Tier 3 clients
If you are below target, direct upsell efforts at Tier 1 and Tier 2 first. These are your best opportunities for deepening relationships and growing fee income.
Sorting Your Findings
Different gaps require different responses and different implementation timeframes. Not every one needs to be addressed before year-end. You should be able to assign each gap to one of four different outcomes (this will help you determine what to focus on in Q4 and what to defer until next year).
Proceed with a solution when you know which clients are affected, have a reasonable idea why the gap exists, and have the time to act on it.
Pilot when you might know the cause but need to test it. Pick a small test group, write down the question your pilot program is meant to answer, and then set a date to review your results.
Defer to next year if the gap is an issue, but there’s another one that needs to be closed first, or if your team won’t have the capacity until you change processes or hire for another position.
Decline implementing a solution if closing the gap wouldn’t change an outcome for the clients involved or the cost of covering the solution exceeds the fee income gained. An example of this would be pushing positive pay on a client who only writes a few low-value checks a year.
Gap Analysis: Addressing Priority 1s
After reviewing your metrics, pick the two or three largest gaps in your own program. The following three are common starting points:
Positive Pay Adoption (Below 50%)
Positive pay is the single most effective control against check fraud. A low adoption rate may leave clients exposed and the bank without recurring fee income, but whether that describes your portfolio depends on who the non-adopters are.
Fix before year-end:
1. Segment clients by check volume and identify the top 50 clients writing 10 or more checks a month without positive pay
2. Call 5-10 of those clients first and ask why they don’t have it enabled. Their answers will tell you whether the problem is price, awareness, or fit.
3. Run outreach to the rest over the remainder of the month and during December, using the 15-minute conversation framework from the September blog.
4. Treat 25 conversions out of 50 clients as a test of your assumption, not a promise to your leadership.
Likely outcome: pilot program.
Track the change in adoption rate, new implementations, and fee income from the new accounts.
Fraud Review Completion Rate (Below 80%)
Fraud reviews are where you can surface gaps and start upsell conversations. Low completion rates on these reviews leave both income and client trust on the table, and the cause can be anything from low capacity to scheduling issues or incorrect tier assignments.
Fix before year-end:
1. Check the fraud review calendar and identify the Tier 1 and Tier 2 clients not reviewed in the past 6-12 months.
2. Allocate the hours a full calendar needs according to the hours your TM officers have for proactive work.
3. Schedule makeup reviews in November and December for the highest-priority clients.
4. Decide whether the team can stick with a quarterly or semi-annual review cadence in 2027. If not, adjust your tiers or plan for added capacity accordingly.
Likely outcome: proceed with makeup reviews for Tier 1 clients over the rest of the quarter but defer making the decision on the 2027 review cadence until you’ve counted hours.
Track makeup reviews completed, gaps found, and upsells closed.
Low Upsell Conversion Rate (Below 30%)
If you’re identifying gaps but recommendations aren’t converting, the problem is either positioning, follow-up, or both.
Fix before year-end:
1. Pull the CRM notes for the last 20 product recommendations that didn’t convert. Record the gap, the recommendation, and the objection the client raised.
2. Look for patterns. Clients may be having an issue with the price, the effort required for implementation, or a lack of urgency.
3. Adjust your positioning and follow-up process based on what you find, and compare Q1 2027 conversion numbers with those of Q4 2026.
20 cases is a small sample size, so don’t treat your findings as gospel. Conform your hypothesis in Q4.
Likely outcome: pilot a revised approach with one or two TM officers.
Setting 2027 Goals That Foster Improvement
Most treasury management teams set volume goals for the coming year, such as increasing fee income by 10% or add 50 new relationships, without setting the process goals that would actually create that volume.
Process goals are more tangible and easier to act on because your team can control the outcomes much more directly than they can for your volume goals.
For an actionable new year plan, set the following three types of goals:
Outcome goals (what you want to achieve):
· Increase total treasury management fee income by 12% year-over-year
· Increase positive pay adoption rate to 75%
· Increase fraud review completion rate to 90% for Tier 1 clients
Process goals (what you need to do to achieve outcomes)
· Conduct 120 fraud reviews in 2027 (10 per month)
· Contact 100 clients about positive pay adoption through a proactive outreach campaign
· Hold 30-day activation check-ins for every new product implementation
· Conduct annual TM reviews with 100% of Tier 1 and Tier 2 clients
Capacity and resource goals (what your team needs in order to execute on the above)
· Hire or promote a TM implementation specialist by March 2027 to reduce the RM workload
· Build fraud review tracking dashboards by January 2027
· Document upsell conversation frameworks and objection responses by February 2027
Each of the above numbers is an example. When you plan your goals, replace those numbers with ones that work for your institution, based on historical data.
If you don’t have historical figures to draw on, wait until you’ve collected Q1 data and use that as your baseline.
Your November/December Action Plan
Weeks 1 and 2 of November: Data Review and Gap Identification
· Pull your five core metrics (from earlier in the article)
· Segment each by client tier
· Identify the two or three largest gaps and sort each into proceed, pilot, defer, or decline
Weeks 3 and 4 of November: Reaching Out
· Call a small sample of clients who are relevant to each gap you’re piloting a solution for.
· Launch positive pay outreach to the top 50 clients without it.
· Schedule makeup fraud reviews for Tier 1 clients not reviewed in the past 6 months.
· Contact clients with dormant products to learn whether they need training, removal, or re-onboarding.
Weeks 1 and 2 of December: Follow-Up and Conversion Push
· Follow up on the November positive pay outreach
· Complete the scheduled makeup fraud reviews
· Revisit pending upsells that stalled because your clients needed more time to think.
· Hold 30-day activation check-ins for products implemented in October and November
Weeks 3 and 4 of December: Goal-Setting and 2027 Planning
· Finalize 2027 outcome, process, and capacity goals using the data gathered from November pilot programs
· Build the 2027 fraud review calendar and load it into the CRM
· Document the process changes you identified
· Brief your TM team on the priorities for 2027
Presenting Year-End Results to Leadership
When presenting your year-end Treasury management portfolio review to senior leadership, your presentation should clearly show the outcome and how many of your hypotheses are actually confirmed:
Slide 1: Executive Summary
· Total TM fee income (YOY comparison)
· Number of TM relationships (YOY comparison)
· Average fee income per relationship (YOY comparison)
· Key wins, such as "Increased positive pay adoption by 15 percentage points" or "Completed 95% of scheduled Tier 1 fraud reviews.”
Slide 2: Product Adoption and Utilization Metrics
· Table showing adoption rates for each product
· Prior-year comparisons
· Areas of improvement and areas needing attention
Slide 3: Fraud Review and Upsell Performance
· Number of fraud reviews completed
· Completion rate by tier
· Upsell conversion rate
· Total fee income generated from upsells
Slide 4: The Gaps and What You Know About Them
· 2–3 largest gaps identified during year-end review
· Actions taken in November and December to address gaps
· Expected impact in 2027
Slide 5: 2027 Goals and Resource Needs
· Outcome goals
· Process goals
· Capacity and resource needs
Making the Next Decision
If your institution treats year-end portfolio reviews as measurement exercises, you might see incremental improvements. But if you treat them as strategic planning opportunities, you’ll see breakthrough performance numbers in the next 12 months.
And that kind of review starts with the five core metrics in this post. Pull the data, identify the gaps, and fix the 2–3 biggest issues before January. That work will set the foundation for a stronger, more profitable 2027.
Want a roadmap for a profitable review that actually works for your institution? Contact us to speak with one of our experts and get a no-pressure strategy session today.
Related Reads for You
Discover more articles that align with your interests and keep exploring.


